Student’s Causal Explanations for Distribution
نویسندگان
چکیده
This paper presents a case study of two students aged 14-15, as they attempt to make sense of distribution, adopting a range of causal meanings for the variation observed in the animated computer display and in the graphs generated by the simulation. The students’ activity is analysed through dimensions of complex causality. The results indicate support for our conjecture that carefully designed computer simulations can offer new ways for harnessing causality to facilitate students’ meaning-making for variation in distributions of data. In order to bridge the deterministic and the stochastic, the students transfer agency to specially designed active representations of distributional parameters, such as average and speed.
منابع مشابه
Design Buddy: Providing Feedback for Sketched Multi-Modal Causal Explanations
An important problem for engineering students is learning how to communicate. Based on collaborations with engineering design instructors, we are creating a system, Design Buddy, that is intended to help students learn how to explain their designs. The input is a sketched comic strip with graphical annotations that indicate forces and motions, plus a structured language system that enables stud...
متن کاملAn Intelligent Tutor for Kinetic System Modeling
Qualitative reasoning is an effective method for intelligent tutoring systems. It can provides causal explanation of behavior that cannot be achieved by numerical simulation. The causal explanation is obtained based on a set of differential equations. If a student doesn’t understand the explanation, we should explain the reason why the equations hold. Qualitative reasoning cannot answer this qu...
متن کاملCausal and constitutive explanation compared
This article compares causal and constitutive explanation. While scientific inquiry usually addresses both causal and constitutive questions, making the distinction is crucial for a detailed understanding of scientific questions and their interrelations. These explanations have different kinds of explananda and they track different sorts of dependencies. Constitutive explanations do not address...
متن کاملMethods of Modeling and Assisting Causal Understanding in Physical Systems
This paper presents methods for modeling and assisting students’ understanding about causalities between physical quantities based on comparative reasoning. Our tutoring system discusses causalities in an object system with the student by choosing dialogue strategies according to student’s understanding states. The student’s understanding state is represented by the causal network and table. Di...
متن کاملWhy Is There Universal Macro-Behavior? Renormalization Group Explanation As Non-causal Explanation
Renormalization group (RG) methods are an established strategy to explain how it is possible that microscopically different systems exhibit virtually the same macro behavior when undergoing phase-transitions. I argue – in agreement with Robert Batterman – that RG explanations are non-causal explanations. However, Batterman misidentifies the reason why RG explanations are non-causal: it is not t...
متن کامل